“Monday Musings” for Monday December 18, 2017
Volume VII, No. 51/363
Lizst at the Piano, by Josef Danhauser
Holy Week: Beethoven and Al Ghazali’s Birthdays
By: Assad Meymandi, MD, PhD, ScD (Hon), DLFAPA*
(Editor’s note: There are many Holy weeks throughout the year. Starting with the fall season, there is Raas-ol- Sana (Rosh Hashana), Yom Kippur, Ramadan, Thanksgiving and now Advent leading to Christmas, followed by Easter. But I submit that there are other Holy weeks, among them Beethoven’s birthday. Beethoven was born on December 16, 1770, and the incomparable Persian Theologian and poet, Al Ghazali was born on December 19, 1058. This edition of Monday Musings, a reprint, is dedicated to Beethoven and his glorious interpreter, our own North Carolina Symphony (NCS) Music Director, Maestro Grant Llewellyn.
Maestro Llewellyn conducted Beethoven ninth on three occasions here in Raleigh which prompted me to write him this note:
Dear Friend, Maestro Llewellyn:
‘…I have deep regards and respect for your talents, dedication to your family and profession, combining knowledge of music with Maazalian precision and Bersteinian facility and passion to communicate. What a marvelous combination. Good for us, your loyal and loving audience.
Throughout of many years of watching you conduct, I believe Beethoven and Mahler extract the most out of you. I am privileged to not only watch you conduct, but also while watching, take a tour of your brain. I write this note to celebrate these delightful tours, your brain and its trillion plus synapses. A brief explanation is in order:
We have powerful instruments for viewing what is going on inside of the skull, namely visualizing the anatomy of this truly wonderful but mysterious organ, the two to three pound brain. These instruments are Magnetic Resonant Imaging (MRI), Positron Emission Tomography (PET) and functional MRI (fMRI) which not only enable us to view the anatomy of the brain but see and learn how the brain functions, NO, it is NOT with these instruments that I view your brain fully engaged while you conduct, but with the knowledge of neuroanatomy and neurohormonal circuitry of the brain.
It is an enchanting and marvelous site to see your brain’s biochemical neruonic interplay and the anatomical juxtaposition of your brain’s vital organs, such as the Limbic system, thalamus, hypothalamus, amygdala, hippocampus, fornix, mammary bodies and the length of your corpus colosseum. Watching you conduct,, especially the music of Beethoven and Mahler, infuses the viewer with spirituality and invites entrance to the ether of transcendence…What a feat! Thank you for those fascinating tours and thank you for bringing your gifts to North Carolina by being Music Director to our most talented and admirable NC Symphony artists/musicians. Below is for your reading enjoyment,,,’
Love, Joy and Blessings
Beethoven 9 Connects my soul with deepest humanities. Here is an explanation:
The next time you go to Musee d’Orsay in Paris, that unpleasant piece of railroad station, that the former Minister of Culture of France, the late Andres Malraux, transformed into a magnificent museum, go all the way down the hall to the last gallery on the left. There, you will see several paintings of various groups. One of them that stands out is a painting by the 18th century French painter Danhauser. It is the picture of a Parisian salon in the 1830s. It shows Franz Liszt at the piano, and at his knee with her face covered is Countess Marie D’Agoult, a socially prominent Catholic lady who left her husband and children to be one of many Liszt’s mistresses-scandal galore– Next to Marie is Alexander Dumas, next Chopin and his inseparable girlfriend Aurore Dudevant (George Sand) smoking her fat cigar; next to her, the violinist magician contortionist Nicholas Paganini; next, Rossini, the bell canto opera composer (he composed Barber of Seville in 1816), and Victor Hugo. They are all gathered to hear Liszt play Beethoven, and way on top above everybody’s head is a bust of Beethoven in the background of clouds roiling into infinity. Yes, the painting shows Beethoven high above with the Gods…This is how Beethoven was worshipped after his death.
Ludwig van Beethoven was born December 16, 1770, fourteen years younger than Mozart. His childhood was dreadful. Almost every night, he and his brothers, Kasper (Karl) and Nickkolaus had to go on the streets and cajole their drunken father to come home. The gentleman was a severe alcoholic and on a church pension. The family was one step ahead of welfare. Beethoven fought suicidality most of his life and at one point after becoming deaf he actually planned suicide. He wrote a long letter, Heiligenstadt, complaining bitterly about his miserable life and reasons for ending it. But thankfully, he did not go through with his plans. It was after 1799 that he began composing his famous nine symphonies culminating in the incomparable Ninth. Beethoven’s music is not classic, it is not romantic, it is just Beethoven, expressive, full of power, full of life and full of promise and possibilities, something like the writings of Paul and Pauline theology.
Beethoven’s immortal 9th Symphony composed in 1824 is a summation of his life, a summation of all he had learned and had lived for. Almost anywhere in the world, reference to the 9th is without doubt or question Beethoven’s 9th. It is NOT any of the other symphonists such as Schubert, Bruckner, Mahler, etc. It is always Beethoven’s Ninth. No matter where on earth from Ethiopia, Sub-Saharan Africa, to countries of Eastern and Western Europe, and to the countries of South America and down under, Australia, in the circles where there is the slightest familiarity with classical music, when you mention the 9th Symphony, the listener will reflexively say Beethoven. They might not know his full name, they might not know how to spell his name, they might not know anything about his birth date, birth place, the miserable childhood he had with a drunken father, a long suffering violated and abused mother and several younger brothers, but they know it is Beethoven! The 9th Symphony became immortal when it was chosen/adopted to be the National Anthem of the United Europe in 1989 after the fall of the Berlin Wall. Later, because of the national pride and momentum of the newly adopted National Anthem, the currency of Euro was created which is now being used by 320 million people. Beethoven’s nine symphonies are eponymous with might, excellence and inimitability of Beethoven style. In word association games, tissues are associated with Kleenex, cars with Chrysler, psychoanalysis with Freud, chewing gum with Wrigley and yes the 9th with Beethoven. The dean of music critics, Joseph T. Kerman, ordinarily parsimonious in praise and use of adjectives, refers to Beethoven “as belonging to the same salon with Gods, and merging with Gods.”
In the annals of human history, the power of Beethoven’s music, especially his symphonies, most of them curiously composed in minor key, is unparalleled. His 9th is indeed the apotheosis of vigor, vitality, hope, redemption, and possibility, yet it is imbued in sublimity, transcendence and beauty. Reviewing other notables’ remarks about Beethoven’s 9th is equally interesting. Hector Berlioz, a failed medical student, yet brilliant composer and writer, admitted that in some ways the 9th “remained unfathomable to me.” He continued, “In composing the 9th, Beethoven broke some musical laws, and frankly it is so much worse for the law!” Stuart Isacoff, a contemporary NY music critic suggests that “Beethoven’s new forms, new visions, explored new ways in what music could do and what music could say. Beethoven had begun early in his career to construct his compositions out of small cells, which are organically, as if governed by a kind of musical DNA, matured. The 9th unfolds a psychological drama in which themes are declared only to become subsumed in the flame of heavenly bliss.”
The NC Symphony recently performed the 9th under the baton of its talented and energetic music director, Maestro Grant Llewellyn. Beethoven’s 9th, with its final movement for chorus, four vocal soloists and orchestra set to Fredrick’s Shiller’s poem “Ode to Joy,” left the audience ecstatic with extended spontaneous ovations. The RTP audience was blessed by the hundreds of voices of the NC Master Chorale, directed by Dr. Alfred Sturgis, and the Choral Society of Durham Chamber Choir, directed by Rodney Wynkoop, and the four soloists, soprano Jane Jennings, mezzo-soprano Stacey Rishoi, tenor Richard Clement and bass Raymond Aceto. When the celestial voices of the Chorales were singing “Freude, Tochter of Elyzium, deine Zauber binden weider was die Mode stren geteilt; alle mencchen werden Bruder who dein sanfter weilt.” “Joy, daughter of Elysium, your magic again units all that custom harshly torn apart, all men become brothers beneath your gentle hovering wing.” I felt like I was floating among myriads of angels of hope, comfort, promise and beauty. The magic of the 9th approaches Biblical mystery of how miracles occur.
The extensive literature compiled by theologians of repute, among them Dietrich Bonhoeffer (the German theologian imprisoned and executed by Hitler in Flessenburg Concentration Camp at age 39) and the late Paul Tillich of Harvard University, refer to Beethoven’s music as an essential intellectual tool to understand how “magic” turns into “miracle.” The miracle is described as a man, Beethoven, in 1824, at age 53, in spite of his deafness, cantankerous and increasingly world weary and clinically depressed, living in an apartment with leaky roof and minimal toilet facilities, “he bared his soul in a work so stunning in originality, scale and emotional power that virtually every great composer who followed has lived under its shadow.” And in my view, the miracle continues the shadow cast by the 9th is protective and not destructive. It is nurturing and not condescending, it is life giving and not burdensome. That is the miracle of Beethoven’s music. Some theologians compare Beethoven’s personal life to the life of Job, the violated, abused and tortured soul in the old Testament. Yes, Beethoven’s music, especially his 9th, is a miracle.
I have been fortunate to have heard the 9th since my childhood conducted by greats of the music world, Eugene Ormandy, George Szell, George Schulte, Arturo Toscanini, Leonard Bernstein (he conducted the 9th in 1989 when the Berlin Wall came down), Loren Maazel, just to name a few. I believe what Llewellyn and the NC Symphony musicians and the combined Raleigh and Durham chorales produced in Raleigh’s Concert Hall with its superior acoustics, was a memorable and transcendent experience, comparable if not superior to other programs.
*The writer is Adjunct Professor of Psychiatry, University of North Carolina School of Medicine at Chapel Hill, Distinguished Life fellow American Psychiatric Association, and Founding Editor and Editor-in-Chief, Wake County Physician Magazine (1995-2012). He is a dramaturge. Received Raleigh Medal of Art in 2001, inducted to Raleigh Hall of Fame 2013, elected Lifetime Trustee, North Carolina Symphony in 2015, and 2016 recipient of NC Award, Fine Arts.